Extrapolating A Recipe
Hello and welcome back!
A quick disclaimer and a run down of the last few months
1. Life threw me a screwball and I ended up writing for someone else’s cooking blog!
2. This turned out to be a spectacular waste of my time as it wasn’t so much writing as it was linking to other people’s recipes which is about as interesting as it sounds.
Whilst this all ended in January I did get caught up with a trip back home and some other business here and there and so here we find ourselves, several months later with not a post in sight.
Never fear, I am (hopefully) back and ready to go again. Today we are going to explore a mistake that I have made time and time again; not trusting my own intuition.
For reasons which I will not go into here, I have recently found myself needing a refresher on some basic maths. For someone who is fascinated by complex mathematical concepts, I find the actual doing of equations about as intuitive as a monkey would find turning a banana into banana bread. In a moment of desperation I turned to a good friend of mine who, bizarrely enough, studied mathematics before beginning his film degree. He informed me of this one night over a glass of wine (actually, I can’t confirm whether it was a night or a glass of wine but considering the patterns of our friendship, it’s safe to assume) and I was both bemused and astounded and then promptly put that information away into the “interesting facts about friends” files.
So, recently my brain dug up this piece of information and I requested assistance from this friend. Last Thursday I got up at 8 am and subjected the poor soul to my incessant questions and utter failure to grasp basic algebraic concepts. One of the terms he used is “extrapolating an equation” which basically means opening it up and breaking it down into simpler ones to arrive at the answer. I found the term interesting and realised that this isn’t unlike what we do with recipes when we read them for the first time and attempt to make them.
Extrapolating a recipe goes something like this
1) reading the ingredients
2) grouping the ingredients (the most basic example of this is in baking, where you have “wet” and “dry” ingredients
3) combining those ingredients
4) following cooking steps
Easy, non?!
However much I find math unintuitive, I find cooking equally intuitive. Oooooh, could that be presented in an equation?! Anyway, as a result I often find myself staring at a recipe and thinking to myself “Well that just ain’t right, why would you do that?” Time and time again I make the same mistake, I promptly think “No, no, the recipe knows better than me, follow the recipe.” Well, FALSE!
For the sake of demonstrating my point, let’s assess and extrapolate my latest booboo.
I had some left over leeks I needed to use and some delicious hard goats cheese and it dawned on me that I could make savoury muffins. I did a google search as anything that involves baking means I turn into a crazed psychopath who thinks that baking is an exact science and if you do it wrong there goes your whole day.
Anyway, after some searching I found this guy here and thought it sounded pretty good.
Disclaimer: I don’t mean to imply that a fellow blogger’s recipe is a load of crap, simply that there are things within this recipe that make no sense to me, I also chose this particular recipe as it is not the blogger’s own. Rather, it came out of a magazine so hopefully, no one’s feelings get hurt around here.
Anyway… Here is the recipe as it reads
Ingredients
175g plain flour
1 tsp baking powder
Quarter teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda
pinch of salt
50ml milk
1 egg, preferably organic
100ml vegetable oil (I used Rice Bran Oil)
Half a teaspoon mustard – I used Dijon mustard
1 medium leek, washed, trimmed and chopped finely
75g good cheddar cheese, grated finely
Method
1. Preheat oven to 180C and line a muffin tin with 10 cases.
2. Mix together the flour, baking powder, bicarb and salt in a large bowl.
3. Mix together the wet ingredients – all in the same jug to limit washing up: Pour the vegetable oil into a jug to the 100ml mark and then on top of this pour on the milk until the oil and milk together show 150ml. I will look a bit weird and lava-lampish but don’t worry. Dollop in the mustard, crack in an egg and give it a good whisk about with a fork.
4. Pour the wet ingredients into the dry and mix until just combined. You will have a very thick dough. Gently stir in the chopped leeks and grated cheese, but don’t over-work the mixture.
5. Fill the muffin cases, using a heaped dessertspoon of dough for each muffin. They will rise a little on cooking but each muffin is very rich and so quality is key here, rather than quantity.
6. Bake for 25 minutes or until cooked through.
Now for the extrapolating (my own thoughts are in italics)
175g plain flour – fine
1 tsp baking powder – fine
Quarter teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda – fine
pinch of salt – fine
50ml milk – fine
1 egg, preferably organic – fine
100ml vegetable oil (I used Rice Bran Oil) – seems an awful lot of oil for the measure of everything else, but let’s go with it
Half a teaspoon mustard – I used Dijon mustard – meh… leave this out
1 medium leek, washed, trimmed and chopped finely – use two small ones, also, how do you define the size of a leek?
75g good cheddar cheese, grated finely – used hard goat’s cheese instead
So far so good…
1. Preheat oven to 180C and line a muffin tin with 10 cases. – convert to this heathen Fahrenheit system and preheat
2. Mix together the flour, baking powder, bicarb and salt in a large bowl. – yep makes sense
3. Mix together the wet ingredients – all in the same jug to limit washing up: Pour the vegetable oil into a jug to the 100ml mark and then on top of this pour on the milk until the oil and milk together show 150ml. I will look a bit weird and lava-lampish but don’t worry. Dollop in the mustard, crack in an egg and give it a good whisk about with a fork. - still makes sense
4. Pour the wet ingredients into the dry and mix until just combined. You will have a very thick dough. - alarm bells that sounds more like a scone than a muffin… Gently stir in the chopped leeks and grated cheese, but don’t over-work the mixture. – again, sounds like a scone (remember our scone recipe, don’t overwork the dough) plus, how are you supposed to evenly stir in hard fresh leeks and cheese into a hard dough?
5. Fill the muffin cases, using a heaped dessertspoon of dough for each muffin. They will rise a little on cooking but each muffin is very rich and so quality is key here, rather than quantity. – they hardly rose at all plus with all the bits of leek sticking out everywhere, won’t the leek just burn rather than sweeten and caramelize? I don’t like the sound of this at all, but recipe knows best
6. Bake for 25 minutes or until cooked through.
What came out was flat, stumpy little muffins that had the texture of a scone and some burnt leeks sticking out of the tops. It tasted ok, but it didn’t have the texture I was happy with nor was the sweetness and richness of leeks present. So, here is how i would write the recipe (changes are bold)
175g plain flour
1 tsp baking powder
Quarter teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda
pinch of salt
100ml milk
1 egg, preferably organic
100ml vegetable oil
1 medium or two small leeks, washed, trimmed and chopped finely
75g good hard finely grated goat’s cheese
1. Preheat oven to 180C and line a muffin tin with 10 cases
2. In a saucepan melt a little butter and throw in the leeks, salt and cook until leeks start to soften
3. Mix together the flour, baking powder, bicarb, salt, grated cheese and cooked leeks in a large bowl.
4. Mix together the wet ingredients – all in the same jug to limit washing up: Pour the vegetable oil into a jug to the 100ml mark and then on top of this pour on the milk until the oil and milk together show 200ml. I will look a bit weird and lava-lampish but don’t worry. Crack in an egg and give it a good whisk about with a fork
5. Pour the wet ingredients into the dry and mix until just combined. You will have a semi thick dough.
6. Bake until golden and cooked through
And that my friends is how you extrapolate a recipe. To make it abundantly clear, I haven’t actually tested this new recipe (ran out of flour) but I am fairly confident it would work out better. and even if it doesn’t, that isn’t actually the point. The point is to trust yourself. In all the times that I’ve followed a recipe despite thinking it was wrong, my meals turned out meh. Additionally, every single time that I have modified it to what makes sense to me, it turned out far far better. This is a skill that I’ve acquired through years of cooking. I also don’t wish to imply that my way is the be all and end all.
My advice is this, remember what things taste like. For example, I know that leeks are sweet when cooked lightly, so doing that made sense to me. Furthermore, think about texture. If it sounds to you that the leeks wouldn’t easily mix in with the thick though, then they probably won’t, so what’s the alternative? What can you add or subtract from the recipe to “fix it”? In short, extrapolate!
If someone could now please make my modified recipe and get back to me, I’d really appreciate it!
Happy cooking!







